Last Chance - Mother's Day Sale

Last chance - Mother's Day Sale

For moms, thyroid health matters. Save $25 on our thyroid test kit or self-pay membership using code MOMDAY.

Pros and Cons of Removing Your Thyroid

A look at the pros and cons of surgery to remove your thyroid.
Pros and Cons of Removing Your Thyroid
Last updated:
Written by:
Medically Reviewed by:

In this article

A thyroidectomy is a surgical procedure to remove all (total thyroidectomy) or part (partial thyroidectomy) of the thyroid gland. When you have your thyroid gland totally removed, you’ll become hypothyroid and need synthetic thyroid hormone replacement for life. But what if you’re already hypothyroid or have Hashimoto’s thyroiditis? Would there ever be a situation when you might need a thyroidectomy?  Is removing your thyroid ever an option for you? Read on to understand the pros and cons so you can have an informed discussion with your doctor.

Who qualifies for a thyroidectomy?

Thyroidectomy primarily treats thyroid disorders such as thyroid cancer, Graves’ disease and hyperthyroidism, and goiter (an enlarged thyroid). Thyroidectomy may also be performed when there are suspicious nodules or lumps in the thyroid gland that could potentially be cancerous. By removing the thyroid gland, the production of thyroid hormones is controlled, and any potential cancerous or abnormal cells are eliminated. However, after a thyroidectomy, most patients need to take thyroid hormone replacement medication for the rest of their lives to maintain proper thyroid function.

Surgery to remove the thyroid is not typically considered a treatment for hypothyroidism. Traditionally, hypothyroidism is treated with thyroid hormone replacement medication to help return thyroid hormone levels to normal range. Medication usually resolves symptoms in most patients. In some cases, however, patients with active autoimmune Hashimoto’s thyroiditis as the root cause of their hypothyroidism may experience continuing symptoms, and fluctuating thyroid and antibody levels, making it hard to regulate thyroid function and relieve debilitating symptoms. Doctors sometimes recommend thyroid removal for these patients to help reduce antibodies and improve symptoms.

In a study published by the American Thyroid Association, 150 patients aged 18 to 79 were separated into two groups. The first group had received thyroidectomies and was treated with thyroid replacement hormone. The second group was treated with only thyroid replacement hormone. Both groups had elevated thyroid antibody levels and persistent symptoms, despite having normal thyroid levels on blood tests. Results of the study showed that those patients in the group who had thyroid surgery had higher health-related quality of life scores compared to those who only received thyroid hormone replacement.

Pros of removing your thyroid

The most significant advantage of having a thyroidectomy is that it can help reduce or even eliminate symptoms that persist despite other treatments. Removing the thyroid decreases the possibility of relapse or recurrence in thyroid-related disorders.

Remember that after removing the entire thyroid gland, patients must take thyroid hormone for life.

Limited offer

20% off your first Thyroid Test

Test your thyroid levels from home and know your levels in days
Use code GETBETTER at checkout
Use code
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Cons of removing your thyroid

As with any list of pros comes its cons. If you’re considering a thyroidectomy, weigh the benefits and risks and work with your doctor to decide whether it’s an appropriate course of treatment for you. Some of the risks of thyroid surgery include:

  • Bleeding after surgery 
  • Infection after surgery
  • Damage to the parathyroid glands, which can cause hypocalcemia (low calcium levels) or low parathyroid hormone levels
  • Damage to the recurrent laryngeal nerve, which can cause permanent hoarseness, a weakened voice, voice changes, or difficulty speaking to nerve damage to the vocal cords 

While complications are uncommon, it is always best to be aware of them. You can avoid the risk of complications by asking the right questions and being fully prepared with a post-surgery plan.

In addition to the risks of surgery, it’s important to know that everyone with a total thyroidectomy becomes hypothyroid, as removing the thyroid gland eliminates its ability to produce thyroid hormones. Hypothyroidism can result in symptoms such as fatigue, weight gain, and dry skin, requiring lifelong hormone replacement therapy. A partial thyroidectomy can also result in hypothyroidism, requiring supplemental thyroid hormone medication. It is important for patients considering thyroidectomy to discuss these risks with their surgeon and carefully weigh the potential benefits against the potential risks and outcomes. 

Questions to ask your doctor

If you’re ready to discuss the possibility of thyroidectomy with your doctor, come prepared for your appointment with these questions to ask. Because thyroidectomies are performed only for a small percentage of patients, it’s important to ask the right questions to feel secure in your decision, surgeon, and post-surgery care. Questions to ask your doctor include:

  • Why do I need a thyroidectomy?
  • Is a thyroidectomy my last resort for treatment, or are there other forms of treatment we have not explored?
  • How often do you perform thyroidectomies? (You should choose a surgeon who performs a large number of thyroid surgeries annually to reduce any risk of complications)
  • What are your patients’ short- and long-term results?
  • What are the risks of a thyroidectomy?
  • How much of my thyroid gland is being removed?
  • What do you do to help minimize risks, such as bleeding, damage to the vocal cords, or hypocalcemia (low calcium levels)?
  • What kind of preparations or testing do you recommend before surgery?
  • Can you walk me through the surgery steps?
  • What can I expect to experience after surgery?
  • How soon after surgery can I return to everyday life?
  • If I was your daughter/son/child, would you still recommend that I continue with a thyroidectomy?

A note from Paloma

Thyroid surgery is not a standard treatment option for Hashimoto’s and hypothyroidism, and most patients can be treated with medication and lifestyle changes. Our healthcare team at Paloma always strives to put you and your well-being first. If you’d like to chat with one of our doctors about optimally treating your hypothyroidism, contact us and consider signing up for our comprehensive thyroid care membership.

Dealing with Hypothyroidism?  Video chat with a thyroid doctor

Get answers and treatments in minutes without leaving home - anytime. Consult with a U.S. board certified doctor who only treats hypothyroidism via high-quality video. Insurance accepted.


Mayo Clinic. Thyroidectomy - Mayo Clinic. Published 2019.

Mayo Clinic. Thyroidectomy - Mayo Clinic. Published 2019.

Share article:

Neeyaz Zolfaghari

Holistic Nutritionist and Nourishment Coach

Neeyaz Zolfaghari is the founder of Unspoken Nutrition, a nutrition and lifestyle brand dedicated to helping others find and create harmony with their daily habits to support their wellbeing and ‘health’. Her journey began over a decade ago, when she was diagnosed with two autoimmune diseases. Knowing what she learned from her upbringing, Neeyaz turned to nutrition as the first pillar of her healing. As her body began to heal on a physical level, she began to learn how our minds, bodies and souls are all innately connected.  

Now as an Integrative Nutritionist and Patient Advocate, Neeyaz offers the people she works with the support, guidance, and tools they need in order to live a fulfilled life. While Neeyaz initially endeavored to make a difference at the individual level, her vision grew to embrace broader community impacts. She is currently pursuing her Masters in Public Health, serving as a testament to her unwavering commitment to instigate change on a grander scale.

Read more

Is Paloma Right For Me?

Hypothyroidism is a long-term commitment and we’re committed to you. Schedule a free, no-obligation phone consultation with one of our intake specialists to find out more.

Schedule a call
thyroid hormone for hypothyroidism

Find out if Paloma is right for you. Schedule a free call with one of our health care advisors.

Schedule a Call